93 points Mosel Fine Wines - "The 2011er Scharzhofberger Riesling Kabinett offers a stunningly subdued and fresh nose of peach sorbet, grapefruit, floral elements, a touch of smoky slate, and quite some chalky minerals. The wine develops the subtly creamy presence of a Spätlese on the palate but delivers this with incredible precision, off-dry rather than fruity-styled sweetness, and great zest. The finish is finely chiseled, balanced, and elegant. More passion fruit sorbet and a feeling of lightness almost like water), elegance and finesse round off this stunning success. What a great wine! Drink Now-2041" April 2021