96pts Mosel Fine Wines: "AP: 61 25. The 2024 Erdener Prälat Riesling Auslese, as it is referred to on the front label (and with a golden capsule), was made with fully botrytized fruit harvested on over 100-year-old un-grafted vines in all the parcels at 100° Oechsle and was fermented and aged in stainless-steel tank down to sweet levels of residual sugar (78 g/l). It offers a splendidly complex and refined nose, which despite the underlying richness clearly shows elegant notes of candied lemon and grapefruit, tangerine, orange blossom, herbal tea, mint, fine acacia honey, William pear, a hint of passion fruit, and thyme. The wine shows more richness on the palate, as some exotic fruits, melon, and pear come through, yet it remains well wrapped in a blanket of candied citrusy elements, which give an airy side to the whole. The finish is super long, fresh, and airy. This is a gorgeously fresh and pure Prälat Auslese GK. 2034-2064."(12/2025) 95-97pts Fallstaff Magazine: "Spicy nose with LIME blossom, ripe citrus fruit, rock flour, candied lime with air, orange blossom. Lively acidity on the palate, driving sweetness, compact, dense, lots of power and juice, yet cultivated, mineral-infused, savoury, grippy, long, lots of certain ageing potential.-Ulrich Sautter"(11/2025)