95+ points Stephen Tanzer's International Wine Cellar: "Pale, bright yellow. Initially more expressive on the nose than the Preuses, offering orange zest, spices and crushed stone, but quickly went into a shell. Wonderfully sweet, sappy and dense, if less obviously round than the Preuses. The high-pitched flavors of lemon, spice, aromatic herbs, violet and minerals are far easier to taste today than those of the Preuses. Finishes classically dry and juicy, with great lift to its crushed stone flavor." (Jul/Aug 08) 91-93 points and "Don't Miss" from Allen Meadows: "A wonderfully broad, airy and pure nose of primarily subtly spiced dried white flowers nuanced by oyster shell and that seashore character that classic Chablis has introduces rich, powerful and palate staining flavors that possess superb vibrancy on the linear, focused and pure finish. Somewhat surprisingly, this is perhaps not quite as stylish as the Preuses but it's every bit as powerful and long. And like the Preuses, it's entirely possible that this could surprise to the upside by the time it gets to bottle." (Oct 01, 2007)