89-91 Points from Allen Meadows: "This had just been racked due to the extended malo. This is much more primary on the nose and while not raw, it displays none of the aromatic elegance of the Charmes though this aspect should arrive in due course. The rich, sweet and precise medium full flavors evidence ample minerality though the finish is more reserved and borderline austere. Still, there is more material here and I feel confident that the Millandes will be the better wine here with time in bottle." (Burghound, 01/07)